Top Rated Mystery Movies on Amazon Video - Page 172

Fatal Lessons: The Good Teacher

2004

Fatal Lessons: The Good Teacher

2004
3.8
A teacher tutors a student in her home with the intent of taking over the family. Using poisonous herbal teas and other psychological devices, she manipulates the husband into thinking his wife is going crazy.
Dark Reprieve

2007

Dark Reprieve

2007
4.1
Two people Matt and Kate wake up in a closed down prison. They have no idea how they got there, or why they are there. In the prison they encounter several terrors as they look for an exit.
Scared Stiff

1945

Scared Stiff

1945
4
A meek reporter happens upon a murder, an escaped gangster and a stolen jade chess set.
The Girl Next Door

1999

The Girl Next Door

1999
3.2
There's someone peeping through windows so Arthur has been asked to watch the neighbour's eighteen year old daughter while her parents are away. Soon their mutual attraction develops into something that Arthur later regrets.
Dead Girl Summer

2025

Dead Girl Summer

2025
3.5
When Jade goes missing, Avery realizes it eerily mirrors a past tragedy involving the death of their friend, Mia. When Avery learns that Mia was murdered, she soon discovers someone is orchestrating events to make them relive that horrific summer.
Affinity

2025

Affinity

2025
5.3
Chilean martial-arts star Marko Zaror is Bruno, an ex-SEAL struggling with PTSD. He lives a life in fear of his demons until one day when he discovers a beautiful woman with no past of her own. Together they begin to build a life, but when she disappears, Bruno must return to his violent past if he’s going to save her from a shocking conspiracy.
Amish Affair

2024

Amish Affair

2024
9
Hannah moves in with a charismatic Amish leader, Aaron, to help with his ailing wife. Seeking refuge after leaving her Amish community, Hannah is grateful to Aaron and his wife for opening their home to her and giving her work but as she tends to her household chores, the spark between her and Aaron is undeniable. Hannah knows their secret relationship has them both living in sin, so she decides to end it but when Aaron’s wife suspiciously dies, she finds herself framed for murder and fighting to prove her innocence.
Danger in the Dorm

2024

Danger in the Dorm

2024
6
After the murder of her childhood best friend and fellow classmate, Kathleen must catch a killer who's preying on young girls around campus.
Applewood

2022

Applewood

2022
4.3
A young widow's latent psychic powers reveal dark secrets inside of a Victorian mansion, forcing her to solve its mysteries before it takes her sanity and her life.
Insane Like Me?

2024

Insane Like Me?

2024
4
A combat veteran returns home after a tour of duty overseas, only to be wrongly convicted of his girlfriend’s disappearance. After his release from a mental asylum, he embarks on a search to uncover the truth and settle the score.
Killer Fortune Teller

2024

Killer Fortune Teller

2024
4.5
After a Tarot card reader predicts a chance meeting, Shane starts to believe in fate, seeking further advice for both his love life and his business.
Dark Feathers: Dance of the Geisha

2024

Dark Feathers: Dance of the Geisha

2024
4.2
A young woman must choose loyalty to a historical Asian clan, and her non-traditional love, amidst the deaths of her dance partners being investigated by her new lover.
Scarlet Winter

2022

Scarlet Winter

2022
5.8
After Mark wakes up to find his girlfriend murdered in bed, he must try to cover up her death and piece together the events of the previous night to find her killer.
Gilded Newport Mysteries: Murder at the Breakers

2024

Gilded Newport Mysteries: Murder at the Breakers

2024
5.8
It's July 1895 and the New York elite have decamped to Newport, Rhode Island for a summer of balls, garden parties, and yacht races. Covering these events for the women's pages of the Newport Observer is Emma Vanderbilt-Cross, a fearless twenty-one-year-old writer with family ties to the wealthy Vanderbilt family.
The Monster Beneath Us

2025

The Monster Beneath Us

2025
7.3
Yorkshire, 1898. A grieving woman and her son move back to the unoccupied house of her ex husband, recently found dead, but they discover that they are not alone inside the house.
The Unrighteous

2024

The Unrighteous

2024
5.2
In an old multi-family house, Wonjung Villa, Joo-hyun casually puts the missionary paper of the cult-church received by accident into the mailbox of Shin-hye. Shin-hye gradually devotes herself to the church and passionately evangelizes her neighbors for treating her sick son.
A Dark Way Out

2023

A Dark Way Out

2023
2.8
When a self-centered petty thief gets wind that a lavish home will be vacant for the weekend, he decides to take advantage. After breaking in and filling his bag with loot, he realizes the house he's robbing is already being robbed.
Death After Dusk

2024

Death After Dusk

2024
7.2
In the town of Buck Creek in 1899, the residents live in fear from a murderer known as the Buck Creek Killer. The sheriff decides to assemble a team of nine bounty hunters to track down and eliminate the ruthless killer once and for all.
Murder at the Murder Mystery Party

2023

Murder at the Murder Mystery Party

2023
1.8
When struggling young actress Clara Edwards sneaks into an elusive, exclusive Murder Mystery Party, she finds herself among a bevy of beautiful, famous Hollywood elite who are suddenly trapped inside, and have been pit in a game of wits where the murder itself turns out to be all too real.
Adalynn

2023

Adalynn

2023
3.5
In order to keep herself and her newborn baby alive, a mother must fight to overcome postpartum depression, grief, inner demons, sinister impulses, and an unseen tormentor until her husband can return home from his business trip to help her.