Top Rated Mystery Movies on Plex - Page 35

Ghosts on the Loose

1943

Ghosts on the Loose

1943
4.2
The East Side Kids try to fix up a house for newlyweds, but find the place next door "haunted" by mysterious men.
Fear

1990

Fear

1990
5.6
A psychic helps police solve murders by mentally linking with the murderer. Then she discovers a murderer with the same talent, who wants to share the fear of his victims with her!
Circus of Fear

1966

Circus of Fear

1966
5.2
A circus becomes the location for stolen loot and murder.
Straight On Till Morning

1972

Straight On Till Morning

1972
5.7
Brenda, a timid, withdrawn woman, meets Peter, a man she believes is finally the love of her life. However, little does Brenda know that Peter is a vicious serial killer.
Happy Hell Night

1991

Happy Hell Night

1991
4.7
25 years ago at Winfield College, psycho-priest Zachary Malius murdered seven frat boys and was put away in the local asylum. Now, however, the same fraternity stages a prank from which Malius is inadvertently set free and returns to the house to repeat his crime...
The 39 Steps

1959

The 39 Steps

1959
6.2
In London, a diplomat accidentally becomes involved in the death of a British agent who's after a spy ring that covets British military secrets.
Mercy

2000

Mercy

2000
5.1
Detective Catherine Palmer is on the trail of an elusive serial killer. During her investigation she meets Vickie Kittrie, who belongs to an exclusive club of women who engage in secret sessions of bondage and S&M. Matters become even more complicated when Palmer finds herself attracted to Kittrie, leading to a brief lesbian encounter. Palmer soon learns that each victim belonged to this club of prominent, sexually experimental women. In order to catch the killer, Catherine must trust Vickie to guide her through the dangerous and illicit underground.
Muzzle: City of Wolves

2025

Muzzle: City of Wolves

2025
6.4
LAPD officer Jake Rosser endeavors to lead a peaceful life with his family and retired K-9 officer, Socks. However, tranquility dissolves into chaos when a gang targets them in a brutal attack. Alongside his new K-9 partner Argos, Jake launches into a relentless pursuit of justice, determined to protect his loved ones.
Strictly Confidential

2024

Strictly Confidential

2024
5.2
A haunted young woman finds herself drawn into a world of seduction, duplicity and betrayal as she desperately tries to uncover the mystery surrounding her best friend's suicide.
Save Me from Everything

2021

Save Me from Everything

2021
5.8
This elevated horror tale follows the emotionally unstable Emmy, who is led to Ireland where a Stranger guides her investigation of a family curse and its sinister origins.
The Fearway

2023

The Fearway

2023
4.6
A young couple travelling down the freeway seem to be unable to get off the road after being hunted by someone intent on keeping them on the road.
Mid-Century

2022

Mid-Century

2022
4.4
A husband and wife's weekend in a mid-century modern vacation rental turns deadly when the husband discovers the owner is a psychopath with a backyard of buried secrets and designs on his wife.
Silent Hours

2021

Silent Hours

2021
5.2
Private detective John Duval, an ex-lieutenant commander in the Royal Navy and Naval Intelligence, finds himself the prime suspect in a police hunt for a sexual killer when three women are brutally murdered.
Through Black Spruce

2019

Through Black Spruce

2019
5.2
The disappearance of a young Cree woman in Toronto traumatizes her Northern Ontario family, and sends her twin sister on a journey south to find her.
Let's Scare Julie

2020

Let's Scare Julie

2020
4.1
When a group of teen girls set out to scare the reclusive girl next door, what seems like a simple prank goes horribly wrong.
Against the Night

2017

Against the Night

2017
4.3
A group of friends sneak into an abandoned prison with the intention of making a ghost hunting video, until they start to go missing one by one.
Insane

2016

Insane

2016
6.7
A woman gets kidnapped in the middle of the day and is tortured in a psychiatric hospital. A Journalist gets on the trace of the case and tries to find out the truth.
The Living

2014

The Living

2014
5.5
After beating his wife in an alcohol-fueled rage, a man (Fran Kranz) tries to redeem himself, while his brother-in-law (Kenny Wormald) hires a hit man to kill him.
Hazard Jack

2014

Hazard Jack

2014
4.2
Terror-Creatures from the Grave

1965

Terror-Creatures from the Grave

1965
5.9
An attorney arrives at a castle to settle the estate of its recently deceased owner. The owner's wife and daughter reveal that he was someone who was able to summon the souls of ancient plague victims and, in fact, his spirit was roaming the castle at that very moment. Soon occupants of the castle begin to die off in gruesome, violent ways.