Top Rated Mystery Movies on Plex - Page 44

American Sweatshop

2025

American Sweatshop

2025
5.1
A content moderator is tasked with purging offensive media from the internet. When she witnesses a crime in a video, she is lured away from the safety of her keyboard as she obsessively seeks to hold someone accountable.
The Sin

2024

The Sin

2024
6.4
A group of actors and production staff, upon arriving at a rural abandoned school for filming, find themselves enveloped in a mysterious energy from the first day of filming itself. The situation takes a drastic turn after they encounter an entity that should not have been awakened. They now strive to escape from it.
Cryptid

2022

Cryptid

2022
4.5
A small rural town in Maine is shocked as a mysterious animal leaves a local resident brutally ripped apart. Deemed to be a random bear attack by town officials, freelance journalist Max Frome suspects it might be something more.
In the Light of the Night

2022

In the Light of the Night

2022
5.7
A young woman attempting to restore an abandoned mill in a remote area soon discovers the place harbors a dangerous creature.
DEEMO Memorial Keys

2022

DEEMO Memorial Keys

2022
7.5
Deemo is a lonely individual who lives in solitude, playing the piano in a castle. One day, a girl who has lost her memory falls from the sky. Wanting to help her recover her memories and return to her world, Deemo discovers that a tree kept atop the piano will grow whenever the piano is played.
Roh

2020

Roh

2020
5.3
Cut off from civilisation, a single mother puts her children on high alert when they bring home a young girl caked in clay. She tells of spirits and spirit hunters, but these are not mere superstitions. As more strangers show up on her doorstep, she quickly finds another reason to fear the forest.
Hellmington

2018

Hellmington

2018
4.9
A detective investigates her father's dying words; the name of a girl who has been missing for 9 years.
Washed Away

2017

Washed Away

2017
5.5
After the death of her husband, a woman tries to get on with her life, but during a business trip she spots him alive and comes to realize that he faked his death.
Subterranea

2015

Subterranea

2015
4.3
Having spent his entire life in a dark cell, never seeing the light of day or another human being, the "Captive" is released into society and must learn how to live for the first time as an adult.
Terrified

1995

Terrified

1995
4.1
Traumatized after witnessing her jealous husband kill her adulterous lover and then himself, an unbalanced, nymphomaniac young woman finds herself stalked by an unknown assailant, but she cannot make anyone believe her desperate situation.
Such Good People

2014

Such Good People

2014
5.3
A young couple discovers a secret room filled with cash while house-sitting for rich friends who die while out of the country.
The Tale of Sweeney Todd

1998

The Tale of Sweeney Todd

1998
5.5
The fictional tale of the murderous 19th century barber (Ben Kinglsey) who sold his kills to a neighboring butcher (Joanna Lumley) for her renowned meat pies. A young innocent (Selina Boyack) and the dashing inspector (Campbell Scott) who tries to solve the murders are also thrown into the mix.
Leave

2011

Leave

2011
6.3
Henry Harper is a successful novelist who has it all. But after surviving a recent trauma he finds himself haunted by a dream that terrifies him. Convinced that the only way to understand what the dream means is to write his way through it, Henry decides to go to a remote second home to begin work on his next novel, a thriller. While on his way there he encounters a strangely familiar drifter who confronts him with information that threatens to turn everything he knows to be true, upside down. Written by producer
The Black Raven

1943

The Black Raven

1943
5.2
One dark and stormy night, an escaped convict, an embezzler, a runaway daughter, her intended and her father, and a gangster take refuge in a remote inn called "The Black Raven" after the nickname of a second gangster who owns it; and murder ensues.
The Devil's Teardrop

2010

The Devil's Teardrop

2010
6.3
When a man known only as "The Digger" opens fire in a train station many are left dead. The only clue the FBI has is a hand written letter with demands on it. Agent Margurete needs help analyzing it and the best is retired specialist Kincaid.
Shadows on the Stairs

1941

Shadows on the Stairs

1941
5.1
Occupants of a London boarding house become suspects as a string of murders are discovered.
Stranger Eyes

2024

Stranger Eyes

2024
7
After the mysterious disappearance of their baby daughter, a young couple receives strange videos and realizes someone has been filming their daily life — even in their most intimate moments. The police set up surveillance around their home to catch the voyeur but the family starts to crumble as secrets unravel under the scrutiny of eyes watching them from all sides.
Blood Honey

2017

Blood Honey

2017
4.8
Tortured by the memory of a childhood trauma, a woman returns after a decade to her family's fly-in hunting lodge to assist her siblings with their dying father, only to find herself stuck in a life threatening nightmare.
The Eyes

2017

The Eyes

2017
5.2
6 strangers are kidnapped and through governmental technology have proof they have all killed before and are told 5 will die this night, one may walk, and the six have 2 hours to decide who gets to live.
Beach House

2017

Beach House

2017
4.9
Emma's quiet beach retreat takes an unsettling turn with the arrival of an enigmatic artist out of her mother's past. He challenges, enthralls, and frightens her, as she comes to suspect him of a terrible crime.