Top Rated Mystery Movies on Plex - Page 56

A Tale of Five Cities

1951

A Tale of Five Cities

1951
4.9
An Englishman has been working in the US so long he now speaks with an American accent. He is drafted into the British Army during WWII but is injured and loses his memory. Because he talks like an American, the doctors repatriate him to the States where he is housed with a New York family. After the war they all travel throughout Europe, searching for the women he still remembers in the hope of restoring his lost memory
Past Obsessions

2011

Past Obsessions

2011
4.4
To the outside world, it would appear Shane Walsh (Josie Davis) has it all - a wealthy and loving husband, a beautiful home, and a lavish lifestyle... but appearances can be deceiving. Matt Walsh (David Millbern) is an attentive and kind husband, but behind closed doors, this monster turns his controlling and jealous rage towards Shane, leaving her battered and bruised. Knowing he will never let her go, she makes the only choice she feels will truly set her free. She must fake her own death and start a new life far away.
Shadow Island Mysteries: Wedding for One

2010

Shadow Island Mysteries: Wedding for One

2010
4.3
TV Movie directed by Gary Yates. Claire is hosting her best friend's wedding. Guests arrive, old family conflicts resurface and the night before the wedding, the Groom goes missing. Only Claire knows of Danny's disappearance and she is determined to find him and bring him back before her best friend finds out.
Wall of Secrets

2003

Wall of Secrets

2003
4.2
A young lovely moves to Chicago to be with her husband. They are both amazed at the terrific apartment they obtained for very little rent. Unfortunately this apartment comes with an unsavory history. As if that isn't bad enough, there are sounds and noises in the walls!
When Justice Fails

1999

When Justice Fails

1999
4.9
A detective (Jeff Fahey) investigating the murders of two sex offenders gets involved with a beautiful district attorney (Marlee Matlin) who becomes a main suspect.
The Absent

2011

The Absent

2011
2.8
The town of Liberty has many secrets but the darkest is hidden between twin brothers. Vincent and Oscar Burton are only 10 years old when Oscar finds out his parents are trying to kill him for insurance money. Oscar takes it in to his own hands to protect himself and his twin.
Ed McBain's 87th Precinct: Lightning

1995

Ed McBain's 87th Precinct: Lightning

1995
4.5
In New York two detectives of the 87th precinct are initially baffled by the brutal, ritualistic slayings of several young women. Through good detective work and clues left at the crime scenes by the psychopathic killer, they are able to deduce who the killer's next victim will be. A tense chase ensues as they try to prevent him from continuing his bloody rampage
Evil Judgment

1984

Evil Judgment

1984
4.1
A girl starts her own investigation after the police fail to catch a local serial killer.
Loves Music, Loves To Dance

2001

Loves Music, Loves To Dance

2001
4.1
In order to solve the mystery of her best friend's murder, Darcy decides to date each one of her friend's on-line pals to see which one of them might have something to do with it.
The Ghost and the Guest

1943

The Ghost and the Guest

1943
5.2
Newlyweds Webster and Jackie Frye spend their honeymoon in a sinister old country house. Before long, they are besieged by a gang of crooks, searching for a fortune in diamonds. With the help of chauffeur Harmony Jones, the honeymooners attempt to outsmart the villains.
Stranger in My Bed

2005

Stranger in My Bed

2005
5.6
To escape her abusive spouse, Sarah fakes her own death and flees. Seems like a good plan, right? Sadly, it doesn't take her estranged husband long to get wise and hunt her down. This game between them will turn deadly and it looks like only one will survive.
High Lonesome

1950

High Lonesome

1950
5.1
When a sudden spurt of murders occurs in the Big Bend country, suspicion immediately falls on a young drifter who just moved to the area.
Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To The Moon And Back

2025

Signed, Sealed, Delivered: To The Moon And Back

2025
6.6
The POstables leads an investigation that takes them on the road not only to find the recipient of a lost letter, but also to track down a rock star who holds the keys.
Wishes of the Blue Girl

2024

Wishes of the Blue Girl

2024
3.4
In the emptiness of her vacant house, a young woman encounters unsettling occurrences, leaving her bewildered and questioning their origin. What has transpired in her surroundings, and what mysteries lie concealed within her solitude?
Snow Valley

2024

Snow Valley

2024
4.3
A newly engaged couple's ski weekend goes horribly awry, when an unexpected guest arrives and the house's dark supernatural forces begin to rise.
Half Sisters

2023

Half Sisters

2023
5.1
Two half-sisters who bitterly hate each other become trapped in a farmhouse during a storm, as a couple of murderous intruders terrorize them from outside as they look for their $1M inheritance check.
Invoking Yell

2023

Invoking Yell

2023
6.6
Set in 1990s story of three twenty something women who venture into the woods to shoot a demo tape for their black metal band.
88

2023

88

2023
5.7
The Financial Director for a democratic super PAC behind a frontrunner presidential candidate investigates donations, uncovering a conspiracy.
Resguardado

2019

Resguardado

2019
6
The Last Inn

2021

The Last Inn

2021
3
Laura makes an unplanned stay at a peculiar hotel and is trapped in a life-changing game.