Top Rated Mystery Movies on Plex - Page 59

Shark Island

2024

Shark Island

2024
2.7
A tropical island photoshoot turns deadly when swimsuit models are trapped with a killer and their only escape is through shark-infested waters.
Light From the Tower

2020

Light From the Tower

2020
4.7
A costume designer is sent to the Catskills for an interactive theatre piece set in the 1920s. When she arrives things seem dark, strange and off. She soon realizes she is part of a student film.
The 4bidden Fables

2014

The 4bidden Fables

2014
6
From the imagination of fantasy artist Dorian Cleavenger, comes four short stories of the bizarre and macabre.
One Step

2019

One Step

2019
8.2
When Tadashi sees a girl from his school stood alone on the beach, he becomes determined to find out why.
Daria

2020

Daria

2020
4.3
When Daria disappears after their first date, Marek finds her in a psychiatric hospital. Everything might be part of a disturbing game played by powerful pharmaceutical companies, though the truth may be more frightening than either of them realize.
Shadowplay

2019

Shadowplay

2019
2.5
When a private eye takes a case to find a missing university student, he must explore the deep dark depths of his own mind to uncover the truth around his own childhood disappearance as he tracks down the missing girl.
Ulan

2019

Ulan

2019
5.3
In this coming-of-age-film about self-love, Maya is a girl who has always held a pessimistic view of the rain, reminding her of failed love and other depressing things. Will the rain ever stop her in her journey to overcome past heartaches?
A Deadly Vision

1997

A Deadly Vision

1997
5.2
A waitress who has psychic visions of murders before they happen is asked by a police detective to help find a serial killer.
Last Seen in Idaho

2019

Last Seen in Idaho

2019
5.8
A woman awakens from a coma after a car accident and begins having shocking visions of her future murder. It's a race against the clock as she tries to solve and prevent her own murder.
All Superheroes Must Die 2: The Last Superhero

2016

All Superheroes Must Die 2: The Last Superhero

2016
5.2
In a no holds barred documentary, acclaimed journalist Vicky O'Neil sets out on a quest to uncover the truth behind the murder of small town sweetheart Ally Andrews. What she uncovers, leads her down a dark and twisted rabbit hole into the world of superheroes where she gets the chance of a lifetime, an exclusive interview with Charge, the world's Last Superhero. As he chronicles his mysterious origins and bloody career, Vicky begins to wonder, is he still the hero the world remembers, or has he become the villain we all should fear?
Onus

2016

Onus

2016
5.2
A teenager wakes up near a cliff, injured and unable to remember how he got there. He is chained to a man in a suit and there is a gun gaffer-taped to each of their hands. An unknown person soon sends them shocking instructions of what they must do next, as the horror of the situation unfolds with nail-biting consequences.
Delusion

2016

Delusion

2016
4.2
Three years after the death of Frank's wife a mysterious woman appears. As their attraction grows Frank struggles with reality and his loss. He tries to start over not knowing his choices could lead him to his own downfall.
Heartaches

1947

Heartaches

1947
4.5
Up-and-coming Hollywood actor/crooner, Vic Morton, has a secret. He starts receiving death threats in the mail and an attempt on his life is made. Soon after, two of his associates are murdered. Who is behind it all?
Beyond the Bridge

2015

Beyond the Bridge

2015
6.7
Denial won't end the nightmare --- After two years abroad, art student MARLA SINGER returns to her empty family house to overlook its selling. Her parents died in a car accident and she wants to say goodbye to her past. But a party with old friends and a mysterious drug send her to a bizarre nightmare, from which she seemingly never awakes again.
Apparition of Evil

2014

Apparition of Evil

2014
4.2
Chilling paranormal portmanteau following a researcher who stumbles across a collection of disturbing video evidence she has obtained from a mysterious source including a location recce made by two young filmmakers, Cain and Dion, who venture to the Australian outback in search of an interesting location for their next movie only to discover an ancient swamp spirit called Raluul, and a video diary of a man called Karl Hendry who starts hearing unusual noises once he finds a mysterious doll-house in the attic of his new house in the North of England.
Scarlet's Witch

2014

Scarlet's Witch

2014
7.7
A lonely girl befriend a witch in the woods who has alter motives in this adult fairy tale.
Lash of the Penitentes

1936

Lash of the Penitentes

1936
5.5
Fact and fiction collide in this exploitation flick that employs documentary footage depicting the bizarre self-flagellation rituals of the fanatical Catholic sect known as the Penitentes. Mixed with those truly disturbing sequences is a story concerning a killing in New Mexico, itself inspired by the murder of real-life reporter Carl Taylor as he worked on an article on the Penitentes.
Exposé

1998

Exposé

1998
3.2
Jason Davis is a reporter who gets an anonymous tip that turns him into an eyewitness to a judge's murder.
Secret Lives

2005

Secret Lives

2005
6.5
An art professor is informed that the husband she thought died ten years before has just been murdered. So she starts to research her husband's secret life in search of the reason he disappeared and who might have killed him.
The Castle Project

2013

The Castle Project

2013
4.5
As an architect begins renovations to convert an old castle to a hotel, he uncovers more than he was expecting. He and his team of contractors experience hauntings and find what could be a portal to the afterlife.